Michigan Supreme Court Chief Justice Clifford Taylor has a 10-to-1 campaign contribution advantage over challenger Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Diane Hathaway, according to the latest filings with the Secretary of State.
Taylor reported more than $1.5 million in contributions so far. Hathaway reported just under $150,000 for the period between Sept. 3 and Sept. 26.
These are not trivial sums, but both are a far cry from $20 million. Michigan Supreme Court Justice Robert Young speculated last fall that’s how much it might take to re-elect Taylor. And that’s how much Michigan Democratic Party Chair Mark Brewer said he would spend to defeat Taylor.
With less than a month before the election, it’s not realistic to expect either candidate will come close to raising $20 million in campaign contributions.
But will $20 million actually be spent on Taylor and Hathaway’s behalf?
Not likely, says Michigan Campaign Finance Network Executive Director Rich Robinson.
If that kind of money is spent on the supreme court contest, “it will come from soft-money issue ads. These can appear out of nowhere,” said Robinson.
Robinson said in the last election for governor, Jennifer Granholm and Dick Posthumus were spending $2 million per week in the closing weeks of the campaign, and “that was for total saturation of all the markets.”
If a similar “food fight” (Robinson’s phrase) were to erupt in this year’s MSC campaigns, there simply isn’t enough time left before election day to spend $20 million, according to Robinson.
Robinson said that MCFN recently “made the rounds” at television stations across the state.
“Taylor has ads cued up to go over the last three weeks of the campaign,” he said. The ads will begin to air Oct. 16 in the Detroit area, Lansing and Grand Rapids.
Robinson said that he didn’t see any Hathaway media buys when MCFN conducted its research.
Robinson said that the Judicial Confirmation Network has bought some time as well. There’s no telling what the JCN might run but its website currently features an attack ad against Barack Obama.